Homes: Rent vs. Own: The Sequel

2010-03-08 19:01 - Opinion

First off, plenty of people pointed out to me that I neglected to consider the value of the owned home, post mortgage completion. So I'll repeat the table, with an extra line for that. The resale price is based off of Manhattan Market Report 1996-2005 (find the link in that page). But of course, today we should all know that trusting the value of a home to appreciate (or even not depreciate!) can be very risky, so I included a zero-appreciation figure too.

  Renting Owning
Gross Income $900,000 $900,000
Direct costs $186,571 $227,544
Deductible costs $0 $101,214
Tax Costs $300,000 $266,262
Net Income $413,429 $304,980
Resale income $0 $179,000 to $677,432
Net Income, after resale $413,429 $483,980 to $982,412

Yes, everyone, that makes the picture much rosier for ownership. But that's out on the far edges of Brooklyn. What are the figures deep in the heart of the city? Well, I'll have to guess. I did my best selecting 15 representative sales and rentals of approximately the same type, size, quality, etc. But even my best here is rough, information is limited. That gives a median sale and monthly cost of $399,000 and $784 for owning, and a median monthly cost of $2473 for renting. Using the same numbers from my last post for interest and so on, that gives:

  Renting Owning
Gross Income $900,000 $900,000
Direct costs $542,812 $533,845
Deductible costs $0 $226,823
Tax Costs $300,000 $224,392
Net Income $57,188 $-85,060
Resale income $0 $399,000 to $1,510,029
Net Income, after resale $57,188 $313,940 to $1,452,219

Sheesh. Nearly break even, even if you throw away the house when you're done with it. And way better if you sell it, instead. And I know this income amount probably doesn't make as much sense with a two to three times higher home cost, but the specific number doesn't matter too much, what matters is how it goes up and down after considering the costs.

I'm not sure if renting is comparably worse in Manhattan, or if I didn't pick perfectly representative rentals vs. sales. Either way, factoring in the resale price, even if rent cost only half as much, owning might still come out on top.

I guess it's time for me to eat crow.


No comments!

Post a comment:

  If you do not have an account to log in to yet, register your own account. You will not enter any personal info and need not supply an email address.

You may use Markdown syntax in the comment, but no HTML. Hints:

  • An empty line between text will create a paragraph boundary.
  • Use angle braces around a plain URL to auto-link it: <>.
  • Use this format to create a link with different text showing: [An Example](
  • Use backticks (``), not leading spaces to enclose a code block.

If you are attempting to contact me, ask me a question, etc, please send me a message through the contact form rather than posting a comment here. Thank you. (If you post a comment anyway when it should be a message to me, I'll probably just delete your comment. I don't like clutter.)